Hi there, Jon! Not much experience on my end since I’m newish to this as well, but I can certainly point you in the right direction. =) There are several threads in the men’s section, discussing characteristics and favored traits of each. (Why I was in the guy’s section reading the stuff is beyond me…probably just out of sheer curiosity 
.) This can show you what some of the most popular ones are: PheroTalk Pheromone Forum - View Poll Results There are a series of comments beneath this: ::Poll:: Your Favorite Product/s? that discuss certain people’s preferences and such- especially effects of many pheros, why they like them, and for what. I would say, browse the thread for a bit and get an idea as to what pheros suit your personality, how you’d like people to respond to you, how you YOURSELF want to feel while wearing pheros, etc.
Hope this helps! =D