Hi Emj and welcome.
If any products don’t smell the best to you, you can always cover them with another cologne, this should not impact their effectiveness.
Based on your description, I recommend you try Ammo, which is a great alround product. Very good with attracting the ladies, it has many fans here. I suggest you research it on the main forums. Best of all, this one smells pretty darn good too. 
Another product that is popular with the master pick up artists here is Turn Up the Heat, however be careful not to overdose with this one. Some people also need to use a cover scent.
Some other products that smell good, and assist with communication and comfort are Instant Shine, Instant Honesty, Instant Openness. I suggest you read more about all of these in The Mens Guide then let us know if you have further questions.
Be sure to return and let us know about your results! 