I was considering getting is/b in cookie scent, but wanted to get opinions first. I searched and searched and there wasn’t much input on the cookie scent.
It smells like a chocolate cookie - it’s more of a true chocolate scent than chocolatini ever was (that one used to be boozy amaretto plus chocolate and vanilla- I haven’t smelled the recent stuff but from what I hear it’s no longer very nice). Cookie is a simple scent; boys who like sweet things would like it I think.
The cookie scent is pretty good. Much more chocolaty with a buttery vanilla.
Carrie I’ve been trying to think of what the chocolatini smells like now, I hate to say it because I loved chocolatini so much my first bottle, but it smells like chocolate scented Tilex if there was such a thing. My apple scented Mr. Clean smells better. 
Thanks so much guys! I really really love the chocolate smell. I was so close to getting is/b unscented but will definitely get it in cookie.
Wow, Tilex? I wonder if the fragrance concentrate turned!
I really dislike Tilex, the smell just sticks with me hours after I’ve used it. And yes, to me it now smells like it has a tilex like undertone with chocolate & pheromones dominant. The amaretto and spiciness I can’t detect anymore. I’m still wearing it, but have to apply pink sugar over it now to make up for what I think it has lost. I’ve whined quite a bit about this, I’m relieved others have brought this up and it isn’t just my bottle or sense of smell.
Mmmmmm…L’Air du Tilex…lol.
Quilty! We’re all a buncha whiners! We can’t help it…we all stink!..lol…and are pherosmacked mosta the time…as are those around us! Whatdaya expect? 
Better than callin’ it bitchin’…I suppose. 
I jus wish they’d do sumthin’ 'bout it…oh shut up Bella.