Hi, Tony. I’ll answer your PM here so others can benefit from the answer in the future, too.
You ask what an over 50 guy would be best served wearing. First, let me take the opportunity to welcome you aboard, and tell you that it is a pleasure to have someone ask for help after searching the forums. Thank you for that kindness, from all of us here who try to help. 
I’m not sure if you know this or not, but it sounds like you don’t from some of what you have said: as you age, your pheromone production peaks and then drops off, and after 80 we typically have an almost non-existent pheromone signature. Therefore, the older you are, the more you will have to wear of certain pheromones to “make up the difference”. That is why Tisha suggested Double Ammo (double strength Ammunition). I am not sure all the pheromones in it are double strength, but the androstenone is at 5.0 mcg/spray, instead of the 2.5 per spray that standard Ammo has.
That is probably why you’re thinking your pheromones are “sending out the wrong signal”. It sounds like you’re getting a sort of ghost effect because you don’t have enough pheromones being produced anymore. (The ghost effect also happens sometimes with massive overdoses, as well.)
The secret to attracting women in their 30’s and 40’s (at least concerning pheromones) is to smell like you’re in your prime sexually to them, as well as socially. For this you’re going to do best with a few specific pheromones, which I’ll detail momentarily, but first I’d like to say that since you’re a long time pheromone user, but not yet familiar with all of what Androtics offers, I suggest that you get and use Ammunition above any other single pheromone, and avoid the P series completely. P stands for putative, and these are molecules that may or may not even be pheromones. They are for advanced users, although a lot of less advanced users want to get the results some of them give. Be experienced before using them.
Ammunition is not a single pheromone. It’s a blend of at least three pheromones, and I believe it was originally intended to be the improvement of and response to another product, which has three pheromones in it (androstenone, androsterone, and androstenol). Ammunition works very well, and it is “socially attractive with a sexual kick”, but the primary focus is social. It is well buffered, and if you know what you are looking for when it comes to “womanspeak”, mainly their body language, you’ll notice that 2-3 sprays of this will frequently get you the attention of women once they have been close enough to be affected. The age group responding strongest will be the one to whom the amount of androstenone you are wearing is most attractive, but Ammunition is also of interest to younger women. I have seen mother/daughter combos both hit from this at the same time, and get into “looks only” arguments because of it. (Not often, but it does happen.)
Women in their 30’s to 40’s should respond best to between 5 and 15 mcg of androstenone, and there are 5 mcg per spray in Heavy Ammunition, so as I said, 2-3 sprays, but one is also worth trying as well.
A314 is a very good pheromone for men, also, and it is very masculine and sexy too, but in a decidedly different direction. Where Ammunition is heavily social and the masculinity comes from Androstenone (bad boy sexual pheromone), A314 is a very complex blend of something like 16 pheromones and is primarily composed of the other masculine signature pheromone, androsterone. Instead of being the bad boy signature pheromone, this is the daddy/domestic/settled/mature/refined/provider pheromone, and in A314 it has been tweaked into a high status mode that is very effective for giving you a success and respect vibe which attracts healthy high value women. It also burns this status into their minds, and makes you much more interesting for a long term relationship to these women. I love A314 also, and I have gotten sexual responses from it, but it is primarily sexual to daddy’s girls who love a powerful, high value man.
Mixing the two together is also an option, although I suggest you spend a couple weeks getting to know each product before you start mixing them. I’d suggest a dose for you of 2-3 Heavy Ammo and 2-4 drops of A314. This will give you a very well balanced social/sexual/masculine vibe that makes you attractive, sexy, higher status and still reasonably approachable. It has a very powerful authority figure signature to it. Be careful, though, because too much A314 can make you seem too high value to even talk to. You might be able to wear as much as 6 drops without having this problem, but I’m willing to bet you’ll do best between 2 and 4.
You will also benefit from a pheromone that signals youth, and the primary pheromones that signal youth so far are the androstenols, alpha and beta. These are also the communication inducers. You’ll want to mix these two together for best overall effect, but they are also useful individually. They are the primary ingredients of Instant Openness (Alpha Nol) and Instant Honesty (Beta Nol). You can get them pre-mixed if you like, as Come Talk To Me 2.
Adding a few sprays of CTTM2 to the 2-3 sprays of Heavy Ammo and 2-4 drops of A314 will make you more approachable still, seem younger, and much easier to talk to. It also signals health by proxy, because youth is equated with health to some degree by the people who you affect.
Finally, I would suggest you also consider putting icing on the cake in the form of Instant Shine. This is a mix designed to add shine to you and whatever else you are using, and it works beautifully. The effect is very mood uplifting for most people, and it makes you and them feel good. It also makes them want to be closer to you physically, and at high enough doses, people will get out of their chairs and come over to you to talk. I have seen women do this in both college and at parties. Instant Shine is very much a “come closer” mix, and it leaves them feeling good and associating that with you. You’ll notice that they tend to invade your personal space with this one. For the above mix, I suggest adding it at between 2 and 6 sprays, with the caveat that the more you use, the less dominant you will seem, but it also seems to give a “youth” signal.
Final overall suggested mix:
2-3 sprays Heavy Ammo
2-4 drops of A314
2 sprays each of Instant Openness and Instant Honesty OR 3-4 sprays of CTTM2
2 to 6 sprays of Instant Shine
Now if you can’t or don’t want to get all this, you should prioritize as follows:
- Ammo
- IO/IH or CTTM2
- IS
- A314
Again, I am suggesting a mix because I think this mix will best be the answer you seek, but I also strongly suggest that you spend a couple weeks getting to know each pheromone product on it’s own at various doses.
Thanks for the consideration in asking my opinion, and have fun discovering this new world. I’m always around to answer questions, as are Tisha and SteveO and a lot of others here as well. I look forward to hearing from you about how my suggestions worked!