What’s important is accurately describing the effects of P87, but I think you all are confusing empathy with sympathy. I am going to stay with empathy for describing P87. It is a cold empathy – an empathy without sympathy. Diane says it blocks feeling. I do not concur. P87 certainly does not encourage compassion by itself, but with P86 and Instant Honesty I feel plenty of warmth. You have to get it from someplace other than the P87. That is not a bad choice to have. Just as one cannot realistically feed and shelter every homless person you see on the streets of a large city, I cannot allow myself to fall in love with every pretty face.
As I noted above, P87 has strong effects which will drown out everything else with cold empathy. It needs to be used in small amounts relative to other pheromones in a mix. I see why Diane is wary of wearing it around her husband, who she knows and loves. When you are meeting people though, it provides vital information and you control the level of warmth and connection with other pheromones.
I have found that I like a ratio of 5:1 P86 to P87. That is what I was wearing last night along with a little more TAF than usual, P75 and 15mcg TAC. That seemed to bring out the cold empathy a little too much. There is still a lot to learn about how P87 interacts with other pheros.
For me the most meaningful description of sociopathy is that, unlike the neurotic who is defending against guilt (and the anxiety that comes with it), the sociopath is defending against shame. As a child he received such deep narcissistic wounds that feeling any weakness ever again is unbearable. This Peter Braunstein guy destroyed his life defying a woman’s rejection. PheroQuirk’s psychopath is psychologically incapable of allowing himself to identify emotionally with his victim’s weakness but takes pride in tricking the psychiatrist into believing he does. He must win at all costs even if it means losing big in the long run.
I can see where P87 might appeal to a sociopath, but not only to a sociopath. I do not experience anything inherently evil in P87.