Yea I don’t think JVK has stopped posting at LS. He has had arguments with other members on there before (including some with the well-respected Dr.SmellThis) and kept posting after breaks. I agree JVK is too inflexible on things like Androstenone and the VNO but he does talk about the peer-reviewed available research with discipline and detail unlike a lot of posters who challenge him. Still I have to agree with what MHarris wrote in the early days of the forum (see below) that the official pheromone researchers (like JVK) are too intellectually incestuous…
MHarris (September 29, 2005):
"In case anybody here doesn’t know, Evolutionary Psychology PERFECTLY, and I mean PERFECTLY… outlines the Androsterone and none relationship.
They just don’t use Androsterone and none by name. I doubt most evolutionary psychologists have ever heard of these two pheromones, despite the fact that I made the connection almost immediately… “that’s a Androsterone man they’re talking about!” and “that’s a none man they’re talking about!”.
Evolutionary psychology really does describe two types of men, one who is basically higher in -Androsterone output, and the other higher in -none output. Of course, there’s other pheromones that make a difference, but I’m talking about a predominant signature here, sort of the inverse of the 80/20 rule here.
You get a good text on evolutionary psychology and you’ll learn far more about pheromones than you ever will reading the official pheromone researchers, who tend to be intellectually incestuous.
It’s the cross application of ideas, theories and facts of other fields that leeds to genius. Isn’t doesn’t. This is as true in information and research as it is in genetic pools. Outbreeding rules, and inbreeding sucks
Outbreed!
Michael"